stock ecu vs. s-squared tune remix
I'm the only SRIC peep with no stickers! HA! I am teh rebel.
i own no stickers...
but that's cuz my hooptie is still stock...
and cuz nate didn't have any S2 in stock when i went by.
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 1,447
From: Just when I find the key to success, someone goes and changes the locks.
Car Info: "Why Warthog sir?"
Looking through some vendor websites, Wired Speed Lab has an Invidia DP for $200 plus shipping. That is a really good price. Too bad I don't have the money for it. 
*EDIT* its $200 shipped

*EDIT* its $200 shipped
Last edited by topnotchwrx; May 6, 2005 at 12:48 PM.
Originally Posted by topnotchwrx
Also I don't know if its just me getting used to the way the car is making power now, but it kinda feels like I still get that surge at 5000 RPM. Do you still get that Killian?
And about my peak whp, that really isnt the highpoint of my tune. That combined with the hoses and pulley the driveability of the car is soooo nice! Lag is basically gone, I get full bost around 2.7-2.8k rpms and it is just smooth (even with the cat I have). I dont think the pulley added any whp but it really made the engine feel light and easy to rev. I have to be carefull when I floor it because I'll hit the rev limiter before I know it sometimes
. I'm curious as to how your motor feels with the P & P & valve job.
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 1,447
From: Just when I find the key to success, someone goes and changes the locks.
Car Info: "Why Warthog sir?"
Originally Posted by Killian Maynard
So did Nate say he used what he figured out on my tune on yours as well? I used to get the power dip at 4k then power surge at 5k, but now its virtually seamless. There is still a slight delay around 4.5k but barely noticeable and probably only because now I'm so critical on whats goin gon with it.
And about my peak whp, that really isnt the highpoint of my tune. That combined with the hoses and pulley the driveability of the car is soooo nice! Lag is basically gone, I get full bost around 2.7-2.8k rpms and it is just smooth (even with the cat I have). I dont think the pulley added any whp but it really made the engine feel light and easy to rev. I have to be carefull when I floor it because I'll hit the rev limiter before I know it sometimes
.
I'm curious as to how your motor feels with the P & P & valve job.
And about my peak whp, that really isnt the highpoint of my tune. That combined with the hoses and pulley the driveability of the car is soooo nice! Lag is basically gone, I get full bost around 2.7-2.8k rpms and it is just smooth (even with the cat I have). I dont think the pulley added any whp but it really made the engine feel light and easy to rev. I have to be carefull when I floor it because I'll hit the rev limiter before I know it sometimes
. I'm curious as to how your motor feels with the P & P & valve job.
I haven't really romped through the gears and powerband yet. Just a burst every now and then. I'm still waiting for the ECU to learn.
Also Nate said that he did have to apply some new tricks and do some "weird" things to get me at that tune.
Registered User
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 10,232
From: Front pleated TWill pants...
Car Info: 2004 PSM WRX
Here's probably a stupid question...does S^2 reprogram the ECU when they do a tune? What advantage/disadvantage is this over the AccessTuner? What price range is an S^2 tune going to be?
I have to take my Suby in for it's 30k checkup after 4K more miles, so a tune might be on the plate at that time.
I have to take my Suby in for it's 30k checkup after 4K more miles, so a tune might be on the plate at that time.
Dirty Redhead
iTrader: (10)
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 7,204
From: Commuting? I don't know what that means anymore.
Car Info: 05 WRX Wagon (Crystal Gray)
They can use the Tuner just like they would use the ECUteck that they currently use. It's just a different tool to do the same thing.
Originally Posted by T-Will
Here's probably a stupid question...does S^2 reprogram the ECU when they do a tune? What advantage/disadvantage is this over the AccessTuner? What price range is an S^2 tune going to be?
I have to take my Suby in for it's 30k checkup after 4K more miles, so a tune might be on the plate at that time.
I have to take my Suby in for it's 30k checkup after 4K more miles, so a tune might be on the plate at that time.
The EcuTek and AccessPort debate has been beaten to death. But the major benefit is that you can get a professional who has tuned hundreds of cars and will be able to give you a custom tune. AccessPort gives you more flexability because you can load more maps onto your car, the only problem being that the maps are generic maps made by Cobb.
Now, if you are talking AccessPort + StreetTuner, then the cost of ECUtek is much lower and you'll still get a custom tune. ST will allow you, once you get home, the chance to change parameters if you are brave/skilled enough.
Originally Posted by T-Will
Also, are dyno results in WHP or BHP? Is the standard 227 HP for a stock WRX in WHP or BHP?
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 1,447
From: Just when I find the key to success, someone goes and changes the locks.
Car Info: "Why Warthog sir?"
Originally Posted by T-Will
Here's probably a stupid question...does S^2 reprogram the ECU when they do a tune? What advantage/disadvantage is this over the AccessTuner? What price range is an S^2 tune going to be?
I have to take my Suby in for it's 30k checkup after 4K more miles, so a tune might be on the plate at that time.
I have to take my Suby in for it's 30k checkup after 4K more miles, so a tune might be on the plate at that time.
Originally Posted by T-Will
Also, are dyno results in WHP or BHP? Is the standard 227 HP for a stock WRX in WHP or BHP?
As far as cost, I'm sure Aaron would gladly give you any information you need on that.
And yes the access tuner is sort of Cobbs answer to ECUTek, they both do virtually the same thing. They "reflash" the stock ECU with essentially a new program (the software is changed on the stock hardware).
Dirty Redhead
iTrader: (10)
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 7,204
From: Commuting? I don't know what that means anymore.
Car Info: 05 WRX Wagon (Crystal Gray)
Originally Posted by nKoan
Now, if you are talking AccessPort + StreetTuner, then the cost of ECUtek is much lower and you'll still get a custom tune. ST will allow you, once you get home, the chance to change parameters if you are brave/skilled enough.
And you can switch between pre-tuned maps at home with the tuner without going back to the shop everytime right?
Originally Posted by topnotchwrx
That's what a tune is. Reprograming your ECU to optimize the cars performance. As far as advantages, not many tuners that can use the AccessTuner plus I think you have to have the Accessport to use the AccessTuner so that itself would cost you more than a EcuTek would. I don't know if the AccessTuner has the issue like the UTEC does concerning the way the car performes in altitude changes.
Originally Posted by ericdared81
Isn't the ECUtek $750? Because Tuner would only be a $400 upgrade if you alread have the AccessPort and $995 if you don't.
And you can switch between pre-tuned maps at home with the tuner without going back to the shop everytime right?
And you can switch between pre-tuned maps at home with the tuner without going back to the shop everytime right?
So if you went the route of the AT, you would spend $995 for the hardware, then you would probably have to pay a shop for dyno tuning time assuming you can find a shop that is up and running with the Cobb AT.
The other option is the Cobb Protuner that iirc is essentially like ECUTek, you pay a licensing fee at the shop performing the tune and you end up with a reflash. So you would ahve the one map in that case but if you added the the street tuner I think you may be able to switch maps, sort of like the delt dash for ECUTek?
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 1,447
From: Just when I find the key to success, someone goes and changes the locks.
Car Info: "Why Warthog sir?"
Originally Posted by ericdared81
Isn't the ECUtek $750? Because Tuner would only be a $400 upgrade if you alread have the AccessPort and $995 if you don't.
And you can switch between pre-tuned maps at home with the tuner without going back to the shop everytime right?
And you can switch between pre-tuned maps at home with the tuner without going back to the shop everytime right?
Hey Killian, can you please post your dyno graph. I want to see your "curves"
.


