The new military.
Originally Posted by 1reguL8NSTi
Great your mom's an officer. That makes absolutely ZERO difference to me and saying absolutely nothing of your character. The worst kid in basic training was the son of a General. He made it through basic then ended up getting kicked out of ROTC. And good for you, you have people who work under you. That's great but again I don't care as I am speaking in reference to those you would have subordinate to you in the Army.

Originally Posted by 1reguL8NSTi
The part I quoted of your previous post is all the reason I need to demonstrate to you why you are not nor will ever be even a satisfactory leader of troops. Until you are willing to die for your country (which you posts clearly states you are not) don't even talk to me about what you could or should be in the military. As far as I am concerned this topic is closed for discussion. There is little else you can argue after making a statement like that. Thanks for putting your foot in your mouth. I know the rest of us appreciate it.
Originally Posted by Unregistered
Again you are a fool. Im not afraid to die for causes I believe in.
Originally Posted by gpatmac
You don't increase your chances of dying by going to war.
Really? I would think you would. If not I'll admit im wrong but I would love to see other wise? I thought the more risk you put yourself in the higher chance you have of getting killed. For example I drive down the road at a speed of 50 mph. Let say I start going 200 mph. I have a higher risk of dying going 200 mph. Thats the logic I used. I could be wrong though.
I want to start out by apoligizing for the "fondling" comment. It was unprofessional and I shouldn't have dropped to that level. But, in return, I do ask that you stop all the name calling too. It is very childish on both our parts.
Now, on to other things. I honestly don't think you understand how the military rank system works. You said something about how I could never be the rank you could be if you signed up. You are right, but I don't think you understand why. The military is divided into 2 rank groups. Enlisted people, like myself, enlist for a set amount of years and thats it. Of course, we can reenlist near the end of our tour if we are selected to and choose to do so. The Air Force, which I am in, promotes enlisted people by TIG (time in grade aka. how long you have been at your rank), TIS (time in service aka. how long you have been in the military), EPRs (evaluation performance reports), and yearly testing once you have met the previous TIG and TIS requirements. This is a very basic explanation, however it is a LOT more complicated than this. The highset rank ANYONE can obtain as an enlisted person is E-9. However, officers work in a tottally different rank bracket. They are commisioned at their rank, they do not enlist. In the AF, there is USUALLY a set amount of time they have to stay in in order to pay for the schooling the AF has sent them to. Once that time is up, they can leave. They are no longer in a contract with the AF other than they are a military member thus held to military standards and subject to the UCMJ. They usually get their first few ranks, up to Capt., automatically after they are in for a set amount of time. (I believe it is 2 yrs from 2LT to 1LT, and another 2 yrs to Capt.) After that, it becomes VERY political! During this initial period in an officers career, they are usually stuck with an NCO to teach them everything about their job. It is in this period that makes or breaks an officer in my opinion. They will either develop a deep respect for the NCO corps, and turn out to be great leaders, or they will think they are better and turn into horrible leaders that will eventually get transferred to a desk job, or otherwise put in a position where they will NEVER have any subbordinates.
There are also Warrant officers in the other branches, (Army, Marine, Navy, CG). They are usually the most repected people in the military. They are in between enlisted and officer ranks, and are usually EXPERTS in the career field. The AF, however does not have these due to the very technical nature of our branch and the fact that so many of us already have degree in our respective job.
I hope you understand now what I mean when I said you are right, but don't know why. And enlisted person, like me, cannot be promoted to an officer, and an officer cannot be demoted to enlisted rank. An enlisted person can apply for a commision, go to OCS/OTS and eventually be commisioned as an officer. It is similar with the warrant officer rank. E1 thru E9 is lower ranking than W1 thru W5, which is in turn, lower ranking that O1 thru O10 ranks. However, please don't think for even a second, that an O1 has more leadership abilities/pull/clout/power or whatever you want to call it just because he is an O1. The enlisted and warrant officer ranks will still salute the O1 and give all the customs and coutesies that are expected of that rank, but that LT will likely not be bossing anyone around. (Especially not the higher enlisted ranks and ,God knows, not the Warrant Officer ranks!) And yes, I HAVE seen a MSGT break a Capt down to tears. Yes it was unproffesional, but it DID happen. I have seen on multiple occasions jr officers get told off by Sr NCOs. Granted, it probably doesn't happen in other branches (Army/Marines)because their officers have a deeper respect for their troops
As far as the NCO running the military comment, they do! Sure officers make all the political decisions, attend all the lucheaons and meeting, and do all the hobknobbing. NCOs are the ones with the hands on experience, respect of their men, and overall leadership ability that keeps ALL the branches going from day to day. NCOs are the heart and sole of Esprit D' Corps, they are what hold the military together. 1regul8nsti said it himself, he makes the decisions but he relies on his NCO's experience. This is how mutual repect develops between officer and enlisted, and I can tell, he will likely make a great CO!
Lastly, I don't think you have PROVEN anything to us reguarding the possible rank you could be commisioned at. I will give you that chance if you want. Get in contact with your nearest recruiter. Tell him about this discussion, and ask him what rank you could be commisioned at. Post his name on here and i will contact him via AF Global email, and i will post the email i get from him here. If you truly believe what you say, this is your way to prove it.
Now, on to other things. I honestly don't think you understand how the military rank system works. You said something about how I could never be the rank you could be if you signed up. You are right, but I don't think you understand why. The military is divided into 2 rank groups. Enlisted people, like myself, enlist for a set amount of years and thats it. Of course, we can reenlist near the end of our tour if we are selected to and choose to do so. The Air Force, which I am in, promotes enlisted people by TIG (time in grade aka. how long you have been at your rank), TIS (time in service aka. how long you have been in the military), EPRs (evaluation performance reports), and yearly testing once you have met the previous TIG and TIS requirements. This is a very basic explanation, however it is a LOT more complicated than this. The highset rank ANYONE can obtain as an enlisted person is E-9. However, officers work in a tottally different rank bracket. They are commisioned at their rank, they do not enlist. In the AF, there is USUALLY a set amount of time they have to stay in in order to pay for the schooling the AF has sent them to. Once that time is up, they can leave. They are no longer in a contract with the AF other than they are a military member thus held to military standards and subject to the UCMJ. They usually get their first few ranks, up to Capt., automatically after they are in for a set amount of time. (I believe it is 2 yrs from 2LT to 1LT, and another 2 yrs to Capt.) After that, it becomes VERY political! During this initial period in an officers career, they are usually stuck with an NCO to teach them everything about their job. It is in this period that makes or breaks an officer in my opinion. They will either develop a deep respect for the NCO corps, and turn out to be great leaders, or they will think they are better and turn into horrible leaders that will eventually get transferred to a desk job, or otherwise put in a position where they will NEVER have any subbordinates.
There are also Warrant officers in the other branches, (Army, Marine, Navy, CG). They are usually the most repected people in the military. They are in between enlisted and officer ranks, and are usually EXPERTS in the career field. The AF, however does not have these due to the very technical nature of our branch and the fact that so many of us already have degree in our respective job.
I hope you understand now what I mean when I said you are right, but don't know why. And enlisted person, like me, cannot be promoted to an officer, and an officer cannot be demoted to enlisted rank. An enlisted person can apply for a commision, go to OCS/OTS and eventually be commisioned as an officer. It is similar with the warrant officer rank. E1 thru E9 is lower ranking than W1 thru W5, which is in turn, lower ranking that O1 thru O10 ranks. However, please don't think for even a second, that an O1 has more leadership abilities/pull/clout/power or whatever you want to call it just because he is an O1. The enlisted and warrant officer ranks will still salute the O1 and give all the customs and coutesies that are expected of that rank, but that LT will likely not be bossing anyone around. (Especially not the higher enlisted ranks and ,God knows, not the Warrant Officer ranks!) And yes, I HAVE seen a MSGT break a Capt down to tears. Yes it was unproffesional, but it DID happen. I have seen on multiple occasions jr officers get told off by Sr NCOs. Granted, it probably doesn't happen in other branches (Army/Marines)because their officers have a deeper respect for their troops
As far as the NCO running the military comment, they do! Sure officers make all the political decisions, attend all the lucheaons and meeting, and do all the hobknobbing. NCOs are the ones with the hands on experience, respect of their men, and overall leadership ability that keeps ALL the branches going from day to day. NCOs are the heart and sole of Esprit D' Corps, they are what hold the military together. 1regul8nsti said it himself, he makes the decisions but he relies on his NCO's experience. This is how mutual repect develops between officer and enlisted, and I can tell, he will likely make a great CO!
Lastly, I don't think you have PROVEN anything to us reguarding the possible rank you could be commisioned at. I will give you that chance if you want. Get in contact with your nearest recruiter. Tell him about this discussion, and ask him what rank you could be commisioned at. Post his name on here and i will contact him via AF Global email, and i will post the email i get from him here. If you truly believe what you say, this is your way to prove it.
VIP Member
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 10,133
From: Lastweek Lane - Watertown, NY
Car Info: 02WRXpseudoSTiWannabeWagon
Originally Posted by lastlaugh
They usually get their first few ranks, up to Capt., automatically after they are in for a set amount of time. (I believe it is 2 yrs from 2LT to 1LT, and another 2 yrs to Capt.)
I think in the Army, it takes either 36 or 42 months to get promoted to CPT.
Originally Posted by lastlaugh
The enlisted and warrant officer ranks will still salute the O1 and give all the customs and coutesies that are expected of that rank, but that LT will likely not be bossing anyone around. (Especially not the higher enlisted ranks and ,God knows, not the Warrant Officer ranks!)
Originally Posted by lastlaugh
As far as the NCO running the military comment, they do! Sure officers make all the political decisions, attend all the lucheaons and meeting, and do all the hobknobbing. NCOs are the ones with the hands on experience, respect of their men, and overall leadership ability that keeps ALL the branches going from day to day. NCOs are the heart and sole of Esprit D' Corps, they are what hold the military together. 1regul8nsti said it himself, he makes the decisions but he relies on his NCO's experience. This is how mutual repect develops between officer and enlisted, and I can tell, he will likely make a great CO!
Anyhow, you bring up a great point but I need to put another slant on this. Officers (Commanders) make all of the decisions in the Army. That's the key distinction between the two rank chains. Officers are responsible for everything that happens or fails to happen.
Based on that, and knowing that the NCO corps is where the majority of knowledge and experience reside, an officer is a fool who makes decisions in a vacuum.
Sure, NCOs make decisions, but everything that an NCO decides is within a stated intent and vision of his commander.
Bottom line, all commissioned officers are commissioned and further promoted by the President. Upon selection to the GO level, Congress has to approve the promotion.
That puts a major amount of accountability on us. If something goes wrong in my unit....it's my fault. There's no question in my mind.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post




