Have you faced an Ethical Dilemma before? Need a good explanation
03-01-2013, 01:13 AM
#16
Registered User
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Sacramento, CA
Posts: 383
Car Info: 2003 WRX
Originally Posted by Heedz
ok easiest to relate to but i cant think of any in my life :/ I need a spark to my memory.
BTW this is a serious question... I have a huge interview tomorrow
"Heedz, tell us about an ethical dilemma you have encountered and the final decision that you made. How did you come to making this decision.. Etc etc"
Keep in mind that if the decision that you made was base on what other people would think of you, it may not be a true "ethical dilemma". IMO a true ethical dilemma will be one in which nobody else knows what you chose to do.
03-01-2013, 01:16 AM
#18
Registered User
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Livermore, CA
Posts: 945
Car Info: EQ Tuned * Corn Juiced '05 WRX
Ahh I see now.
"Heedz, tell us about an ethical dilemma you have encountered and the final decision that you made. How did you come to making this decision.. Etc etc"
Keep in mind that if the decision that you made was base on what other people would think of you, it may not be a true "ethical dilemma". IMO a true ethical dilemma will be one in which nobody else knows what you chose to do.
"Heedz, tell us about an ethical dilemma you have encountered and the final decision that you made. How did you come to making this decision.. Etc etc"
Keep in mind that if the decision that you made was base on what other people would think of you, it may not be a true "ethical dilemma". IMO a true ethical dilemma will be one in which nobody else knows what you chose to do.
Exactly. What you perceive to be an ethical dilemma is different than what someone else might perceive it to be.
So, technically, there is no right or wrong answer to an ethical dilemma...you just have to justify your answer. As long as you backup what you're saying, you're golden.
03-01-2013, 01:41 AM
#19
aka FlukeWRX
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: East Bay
Posts: 3,657
Car Info: '03 WRX WRB Sedan
Exactly. What you perceive to be an ethical dilemma is different than what someone else might perceive it to be.
So, technically, there is no right or wrong answer to an ethical dilemma...you just have to justify your answer. As long as you backup what you're saying, you're golden.
So, technically, there is no right or wrong answer to an ethical dilemma...you just have to justify your answer. As long as you backup what you're saying, you're golden.
03-01-2013, 02:03 AM
#20
Yea, I agree with the notion that there is no wrong answer. They're looking into your reasoning of the answer.
Make a statement, give consideration to the opposing view and their pros and cons, then state your answer and slap dem reasons down and how they relate with the bigger cause.
Driving cars pollute the world, but we do it anyways to make more things accessible and faster than any other means of transportation. We in a sense are polluting the world by choice or are we not? Can you make do staying green? Walk/Bike to work?
Just a sad argument that I figure is easiest for everyone here to relate to. I like the Firemen watching the dude drown as a better ethical dilemma story to consider. That one is plane as day...
This also relates back to Socrates. If a guy is driving to kill you, chasing you. You run a stop sign to avoid dying but you made that choice to break the law at that time to save yourself from greater danger, but get pulled over by the cop. The cop questions you about why you ran the light, and you justify it was because you were threatened by your life. Should the cop bust you on an ticket for breaking the law? Or would they understand that there could be a higher law than the road laws at this point when your being chased and your life is in danger?
Prove it.
Make a statement, give consideration to the opposing view and their pros and cons, then state your answer and slap dem reasons down and how they relate with the bigger cause.
Driving cars pollute the world, but we do it anyways to make more things accessible and faster than any other means of transportation. We in a sense are polluting the world by choice or are we not? Can you make do staying green? Walk/Bike to work?
Just a sad argument that I figure is easiest for everyone here to relate to. I like the Firemen watching the dude drown as a better ethical dilemma story to consider. That one is plane as day...
This also relates back to Socrates. If a guy is driving to kill you, chasing you. You run a stop sign to avoid dying but you made that choice to break the law at that time to save yourself from greater danger, but get pulled over by the cop. The cop questions you about why you ran the light, and you justify it was because you were threatened by your life. Should the cop bust you on an ticket for breaking the law? Or would they understand that there could be a higher law than the road laws at this point when your being chased and your life is in danger?
Prove it.
03-01-2013, 05:13 AM
#21
I'll break one down for you in a Fire/EMS situation.
You have a pulse less/apnic 92 YOF with family on scene, family states she has had a down time of only 5 min prior to calling 9-1-1. She has no DNR and no signs of obvious death.
The ethical dilemma is do you intubate, IV, Meds, shock if needed then transport or start BLS CPR and consult county base to receive termination of CPR and a time of death in the field.
That is going to be a major factor in the EMS world....
Do I give the family false hope and do everything that I can to save Grandma so she can be in a vegative state for the next months-years or do
I contact base for determination of death and explain to the family that she has been expired for too long and their is nothing that you can do to revive her.
I hope this helps as I am sure your interview is for Fire/EMS since you carry turnouts in your Subie like me! Lmao...
Good luck!
You have a pulse less/apnic 92 YOF with family on scene, family states she has had a down time of only 5 min prior to calling 9-1-1. She has no DNR and no signs of obvious death.
The ethical dilemma is do you intubate, IV, Meds, shock if needed then transport or start BLS CPR and consult county base to receive termination of CPR and a time of death in the field.
That is going to be a major factor in the EMS world....
Do I give the family false hope and do everything that I can to save Grandma so she can be in a vegative state for the next months-years or do
I contact base for determination of death and explain to the family that she has been expired for too long and their is nothing that you can do to revive her.
I hope this helps as I am sure your interview is for Fire/EMS since you carry turnouts in your Subie like me! Lmao...
Good luck!
03-01-2013, 08:09 AM
#23
Registered User
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Dec 2012
Location: Bay Area, CA
Posts: 550
Car Info: 04 Forester XT and 06 WRX TR
I was asked the same question during my interview for a promotion in upper management. I dont believe there is a right or wrong answer to that question as long as your answer is relevant and you have something to back up that answer.
I dont know what kind of answer they are looking for but for my recent interview, I stated the following.
-Employee violated safety protocols and ended up hurting himself in the process.
-Prior to the incident, the employee's previous supervisor already placed him on a final warning for a similar incident.
-Now I am faced with either terminating him for violating our company's code of business conduct or let him slide and reinstate the warning since it was his previous supervisor's decision to place him on a final warning, not myself.
I too was concerned about this form of question. So I asked one of the interviewers what the correct answer was, and he said there wasnt any right or wrong answers. It was to gauge how you react to such questions since it really does make u think about your decision, under pressure. You should be fine. Your question was defined several times in this thread, but defining the question is just the first step to answering it. Provide a solid scenario and follow it up with some solid reasoning behind why you chose that path.
I dont know what kind of answer they are looking for but for my recent interview, I stated the following.
-Employee violated safety protocols and ended up hurting himself in the process.
-Prior to the incident, the employee's previous supervisor already placed him on a final warning for a similar incident.
-Now I am faced with either terminating him for violating our company's code of business conduct or let him slide and reinstate the warning since it was his previous supervisor's decision to place him on a final warning, not myself.
I too was concerned about this form of question. So I asked one of the interviewers what the correct answer was, and he said there wasnt any right or wrong answers. It was to gauge how you react to such questions since it really does make u think about your decision, under pressure. You should be fine. Your question was defined several times in this thread, but defining the question is just the first step to answering it. Provide a solid scenario and follow it up with some solid reasoning behind why you chose that path.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
STI RUSH
Bay Area
1
11-10-2008 07:44 AM
soggynoodles
Sacramento & Reno
22
10-27-2005 09:53 AM
bonkers
Engine/Power - EJ20T (pre-2006 WRX and JDM)
21
07-08-2004 08:50 PM
