Teh Politics Forum Rumors and lies and Teh Iraqi Info Minister and much much more...

Would the Last Honest Reporter Please Turn On the Lights?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 10-22-2008, 03:21 PM
  #1  
BanHammer™
Thread Starter
iTrader: (8)
 
Max Xevious's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Wagonmafia Propaganda Lieutenant
Posts: 47,585
Car Info: 2001 Forester RS2 SPEC-F
Would the Last Honest Reporter Please Turn On the Lights?

This is making its way around the internet and thought it was a very good article by Mr. Card.

As the article stated, he is a Democratic columnist.

http://www.meridianmagazine.com/ideas/081017light.html

Editor's note: Orson Scott Card is a Democrat and a newspaper columnist, and in this opinion piece he takes on both while lamenting the current state of journalism.

An open letter to the local daily paper — almost every local daily paper in America:

I remember reading All the President's Men and thinking: That's journalism. You do what it takes to get the truth and you lay it before the public, because the public has a right to know.

This housing crisis didn't come out of nowhere. It was not a vague emanation of the evil Bush administration.

It was a direct result of the political decision, back in the late 1990s, to loosen the rules of lending so that home loans would be more accessible to poor people. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were authorized to approve risky loans.

What is a risky loan? It's a loan that the recipient is likely not to be able to repay.

The goal of this rule change was to help the poor — which especially would help members of minority groups. But how does it help these people to give them a loan that they can't repay? They get into a house, yes, but when they can't make the payments, they lose the house — along with their credit rating.

They end up worse off than before.

This was completely foreseeable and in fact many people did foresee it. One political party, in Congress and in the executive branch, tried repeatedly to tighten up the rules. The other party blocked every such attempt and tried to loosen them.

Furthermore, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae were making political contributions to the very members of Congress who were allowing them to make irresponsible loans. (Though why quasi-federal agencies were allowed to do so baffles me. It's as if the Pentagon were allowed to contribute to the political campaigns of Congressmen who support increasing their budget.)

Isn't there a story here? Doesn't journalism require that you who produce our daily paper tell the truth about who brought us to a position where the only way to keep confidence in our economy was a $700 billion bailout? Aren't you supposed to follow the money and see which politicians were benefiting personally from the deregulation of mortgage lending?

I have no doubt that if these facts had pointed to the Republican Party or to John McCain as the guilty parties, you would be treating it as a vast scandal. "Housing-gate," no doubt. Or "Fannie-gate."

Instead, it was Senator Christopher Dodd and Congressman Barney Frank, both Democrats, who denied that there were any problems, who refused Bush administration requests to set up a regulatory agency to watch over Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and who were still pushing for these agencies to go even further in promoting sub-prime mortgage loans almost up to the minute they failed.

As Thomas Sowell points out in a TownHall.com essay entitled "Do Facts Matter?" ( http://snipurl.com/457townhall_com] ): "Alan Greenspan warned them four years ago. So did the Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers to the President. So did Bush's Secretary of the Treasury."

These are facts. This financial crisis was completely preventable. The party that blocked any attempt to prevent it was ... the Democratic Party. The party that tried to prevent it was ... the Republican Party.

Yet when Nancy Pelosi accused the Bush administration and Republican deregulation of causing the crisis, you in the press did not hold her to account for her lie. Instead, you criticized Republicans who took offense at this lie and refused to vote for the bailout!

What? It's not the liar, but the victims of the lie who are to blame?

Now let's follow the money ... right to the presidential candidate who is the number-two recipient of campaign contributions from Fannie Mae.

And after Freddie Raines, the CEO of Fannie Mae who made $90 million while running it into the ground, was fired for his incompetence, one presidential candidate's campaign actually consulted him for advice on housing.

If that presidential candidate had been John McCain, you would have called it a major scandal and we would be getting stories in your paper every day about how incompetent and corrupt he was.

But instead, that candidate was Barack Obama, and so you have buried this story, and when the McCain campaign dared to call Raines an "adviser" to the Obama campaign — because that campaign had sought his advice — you actually let Obama's people get away with accusing McCain of lying, merely because Raines wasn't listed as an official adviser to the Obama campaign.

You would never tolerate such weasely nit-picking from a Republican.

If you who produce our local daily paper actually had any principles, you would be pounding this story, because the prosperity of all Americans was put at risk by the foolish, short-sighted, politically selfish, and possibly corrupt actions of leading Democrats, including Obama.

If you who produce our local daily paper had any personal honor, you would find it unbearable to let the American people believe that somehow Republicans were to blame for this crisis.

There are precedents. Even though President Bush and his administration never said that Iraq sponsored or was linked to 9/11, you could not stand the fact that Americans had that misapprehension — so you pounded us with the fact that there was no such link. (Along the way, you created the false impression that Bush had lied to them and said that there was a connection.)

If you had any principles, then surely right now, when the American people are set to blame President Bush and John McCain for a crisis they tried to prevent, and are actually shifting to approve of Barack Obama because of a crisis he helped cause, you would be laboring at least as hard to correct that false impression.

Your job, as journalists, is to tell the truth. That's what you claim you do, when you accept people's money to buy or subscribe to your paper.

But right now, you are consenting to or actively promoting a big fat lie — that the housing crisis should somehow be blamed on Bush, McCain, and the Republicans. You have trained the American people to blame everything bad — even bad weather — on Bush, and they are responding as you have taught them to.

If you had any personal honor, each reporter and editor would be insisting on telling the truth — even if it hurts the election chances of your favorite candidate.

Because that's what honorable people do. Honest people tell the truth even when they don't like the probable consequences. That's what honesty means . That's how trust is earned.

Barack Obama is just another politician, and not a very wise one. He has revealed his ignorance and naivete time after time — and you have swept it under the rug, treated it as nothing.

Meanwhile, you have participated in the borking of Sarah Palin, reporting savage attacks on her for the pregnancy of her unmarried daughter — while you ignored the story of John Edwards's own adultery for many months.

So I ask you now: Do you have any standards at all? Do you even know what honesty means?

Is getting people to vote for Barack Obama so important that you will throw away everything that journalism is supposed to stand for?

You might want to remember the way the National Organization of Women threw away their integrity by supporting Bill Clinton despite his well-known pattern of sexual exploitation of powerless women. Who listens to NOW anymore? We know they stand for nothing; they have no principles.

That's where you are right now.

It's not too late. You know that if the situation were reversed, and the truth would damage McCain and help Obama, you would be moving heaven and earth to get the true story out there.

If you want to redeem your honor, you will swallow hard and make a list of all the stories you would print if it were McCain who had been getting money from Fannie Mae, McCain whose campaign had consulted with its discredited former CEO, McCain who had voted against tightening its lending practices.

Then you will print them, even though every one of those true stories will point the finger of blame at the reckless Democratic Party, which put our nation's prosperity at risk so they could feel good about helping the poor, and lay a fair share of the blame at Obama's door.

You will also tell the truth about John McCain: that he tried, as a Senator, to do what it took to prevent this crisis. You will tell the truth about President Bush: that his administration tried more than once to get Congress to regulate lending in a responsible way.

This was a Congress-caused crisis, beginning during the Clinton administration, with Democrats leading the way into the crisis and blocking every effort to get out of it in a timely fashion.

If you at our local daily newspaper continue to let Americans believe — and vote as if — President Bush and the Republicans caused the crisis, then you are joining in that lie.

If you do not tell the truth about the Democrats — including Barack Obama — and do so with the same energy you would use if the miscreants were Republicans — then you are not journalists by any standard.

You're just the public relations machine of the Democratic Party, and it's time you were all fired and real journalists brought in, so that we can actually have a news paper in our city.

This article first appeared in The Rhinoceros Times of Greensboro, North Carolina, and is used here by permission.
Max Xevious is offline  
Old 10-22-2008, 03:43 PM
  #2  
iClub Silver Vendor
iTrader: (25)
 
FW Motorsports's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Participating in some Anarchy!
Posts: 15,494
Car Info: 2005 LGT wagon
This was a Congress-caused crisis, beginning during the Clinton administration, with Democrats leading the way into the crisis and blocking every effort to get out of it in a timely fashion.

If you do not tell the truth about the Democrats — including Barack Obama — and do so with the same energy you would use if the miscreants were Republicans — then you are not journalists by any standard.


A-****ing-men!!!
FW Motorsports is offline  
Old 10-22-2008, 04:25 PM
  #3  
Registered User
 
Superglue WRX's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: I was up above it, now I'm down in it
Posts: 5,686
Car Info: New Government Motors SUV!
I don't think all the blame should be brought to the dems on the crisis as if the republicans we really powerless to change anything. There's still the financial institutions that knowingly lent bad loans and home buyers who knowingly couldn't pay them.

Now that I got that out of the way, I understand where this guy is coming from. The majority of mainstream media is politically liberal and it's very irritating. This was made apparent during the last 2 months of the presidential campaigns. MSNBC basically championed Obama and tried to rip McCain and Palin to shreds. Completely unfair. The only other main stream alternative is Fox which essentially does the opposite.

Unfortunately this business is not about providing unbiased news to the public. It's about business. Do whatever it takes to sell or gain sponsers. I can't even watch Larry King because he literally has a commercial break every 5 minutes. Odds are there's an Obama add during the hour long show as well.

I applaud this man for making a stance and being the voice of so many others. Although I don't like the way he portrays the dems as the sole source of this mess while championing the republicans for doing everything they could to right the ship. You can see his own biased in the letter clear as day, even if he is a democrat it doesn't mean his word is gospel.

At any rate, this kind of blaming and cheering wouldn't be necessary if politicians would drop the partisan bull****. If they would stop siding with their own party and just listened to their constituents- stop accepting their party's agenda an use some independent thought, we would all be better off. The same goes to the public and the heard mentality. Demand the truth and reject all of the spin out there.

Here's to living the dream!
Superglue WRX is offline  
Old 10-22-2008, 04:30 PM
  #4  
VIP Member
iTrader: (3)
 
Nick Koan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: The BLC
Posts: 17,466
Car Info: Legacy GT
This **** sandwich really lands on both sides. McCain's campaign manager and long time friend lobbied for Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae for 5 years (and is rumored to have further accepted money after as well). To me, that's a pretty damn indicting fact, and if the media were really all that one-sided wouldn't we have seen more about that?

Granted, Frank's and Dodd's hands aren't exactly clean, and Pelosi's parting shots on the bailout were pretty stupid, but come on. This isn't an issue of red versus blue, but of politicians who are (at best) too stupid (or at worst) actively working to undermine this nation for personal profit.

I do agree with the main point, though, that journalism is getting weaker and weaker in this country. Its dividing into two camps and pretty soon, there will be no journalism left and it'll all be talking points from one party or the other, or perhaps some newsvertisement about new products we can buy right now!
Nick Koan is offline  
Old 10-22-2008, 04:48 PM
  #5  
VIP Member
iTrader: (3)
 
Nick Koan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: The BLC
Posts: 17,466
Car Info: Legacy GT
Also, they forgot to mention the Orson Scott Card is also a Mormon and a prominent Science Fiction writer, a G.W. Bush supporter, pro-gun control advocate, opposes unrestricted free-market capitalism, along with being a columnist and a registered Democrat. A "Tony Blair" Democrat as he's described it.

He's not exactly a clear-cut political columnist and will frequently cross the lines that the rest of the media have drawn between the two parties. It bothers me when he says "And I say this as a registered Democrat" because it gives the false impression that he's usually a staunchly Democrat supporter, except in whatever specific case he's writing or talking about. He's definitely a much better writer and thinker than that. He uses the media's sand drawn red vs. blue lines to emphasize points, but makes no effort to show that he's more complex than that which can be disingenuous.

But, he's usually a very good read, both in fiction and especially in his non-fiction political columns.
Nick Koan is offline  
Old 10-22-2008, 04:48 PM
  #6  
Registered User
 
Superglue WRX's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: I was up above it, now I'm down in it
Posts: 5,686
Car Info: New Government Motors SUV!
At this point I'd rather go search for the Easter Bunny than try and find unbiased news. The best thing we can do is try and read through the bull****. The media should cover all relevant instead of what's convenient or whatever works best for their spin on it. They have their own damn channels for Christ's sake. They should fill all 24 hours with real and pertinent news. Leave the bias to the viewers.
Superglue WRX is offline  
Old 10-22-2008, 04:54 PM
  #7  
VIP Member
iTrader: (3)
 
Nick Koan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: The BLC
Posts: 17,466
Car Info: Legacy GT
Which is sad, because as Card says, we need to be turning these "journalists" on their heads and decrying the loss of real journalism.

/not like I'm doing anything, I'm just agreeing that we *should*

Last edited by Nick Koan; 10-22-2008 at 04:56 PM.
Nick Koan is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
SlickmisterN
Interior, Exterior & Lighting
8
03-15-2019 04:06 PM
brucelee
Bay Area
12
11-05-2008 10:31 PM
GR8-WRX
Bay Area
0
01-20-2004 02:15 PM
dr3d1zzl3
Bay Area
30
11-13-2003 11:36 AM



Quick Reply: Would the Last Honest Reporter Please Turn On the Lights?



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:34 PM.


Top

© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands



When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.