NewShockerGuy

iTrader: (1)

The only wheels that I want are Advan RC II's in Gold, 17.5 inch.

I love these wheels sooooo much when I saw them, my problem is I see that Rota has ones that look excatly the same, I belive they are called Action. They look identical actually... besides the fact that on one spoke advans say "Advan RC II" where as the rota says nothing...

My question is what makes one better than the other? Is one lighter or stronger? I did notice that the price tag is going to set my back about $1600 for the Advans and only $700 for the Rotas... but are the rotas cheap imations?


See pics.

Thanks,

-Nigel

NewShockerGuy

iTrader: (1)

Advan:


-Nigel

EsoterikWRX

w/o getting into the merits of their respective makers, ask youself if having authentic parts on you car make a difference to you & there's your answer.

hokusai

iTrader: (32)

I have Rota's and i think they are great. I mean, i would want the Advans but i can't affor them. If you can afford them, then get them. If you buy rotas, you can spend the money you "saved" to buy other mods or the tires.

bone324

If you looked at both wheels in person, you would definitely notice a difference. The finish on Rota wheels is not nearly as attractive or durable as most high-end wheels (such as Advan). The Advans are probably forged. Therefore they most likely weigh less and are stronger than Rotas. All of this is personal preference though.

Imprezer

iTrader: (9)

Both wheels will get you from point A to point B.

One is real JDM wheel, and one is a knock-off.

You decide.

NewShockerGuy

iTrader: (1)

Thanks guys, sort of what I had thought... Made up my mind :-)

At gruppe-s he has the following for Advan:


Size: Hole: PCD: Offset

17x7.5: 5 : 114.3 50/45
17x7.5: 5 : 100 48/35


What does this all mean (mainly the PCD and offset?) and which do I get for a wrx?


Thanks,
-Nigel

bone324

PCD is the distance between holes, Subarus are 100. Offset is the distance of the mounting surface from the center of the wheel. You need the 48mm offset for a 17x7.5" wheel.

NewShockerGuy

iTrader: (1)

Thanks again for the replies! I love it.

I'm in PA, so there are flat parts, lots of potholes...etc sort of normal I guess, has a bit of everything...


What does forged mean? I thought all wheels were made the same, cut from a big round chunck of metal... I believe I saw that on a hot rod show... they stuck a round piece of metal on a CNC machine and it made the wheel...


Thanks again :-)

-Nigel

EsoterikWRX

If memory serves, a 'billet' wheel is made like that. But there is 'casting' which is how most alloy wheels are made & forging. To oversimplyfy, casting involves pouring the alloy into a mold, versus 'forging' which is more like forcing the alloy into a mold at very hight pressures. If someone doesn't beat me to it, i'll look up a site w/ better definitions.

http://www.tirerack.com/wheels/tech/construc.htm

TireRack's tech center kicks @$$!