My coupe will be here in 3 weeks, fully loaded, 6spd nav, the works. I'm very tempted to take it instead of the sti. i'm # 5 on my dealers list for the STI, but i'm thinking now that the car is a bit "loud" for my tastes. Although I love the numbers of the car, I'm torn. What do you guys think? I can't have both.

 

ask yourself the question when its raining or snowing(here in MD it snows, alot this year)...the Subbie has 4drs also... practicality and performance to the STI. I do love the G35 coupe...its a beauty... it does look better I think

-shahul x

 

3 cars ago, I had a 2000 Audi S4. Then I got a S2000. Needless to say one performs better in inclimate weather than the other. I would like to wait for the New Gen S4, but rumour has it it will be aroung 45k. To much for me in my current situation. The Sti will be a great car, but only those in the know will understand that, sitting side by side at a stand still, the G35 will be ALOT more attractive. Overall, it's all about the *****, and that's why I'm leaning towards the G35 coupe .

 

45k is too much for you? umm...ok..so u had a 2000 s4, then an s2000, and now another new car? why the new car every year? maybe thats why u cant afford 45k..

 

I have an Avalanche now. I get bored easily you know. But I draw the line at 40k that's why it's too much. If I wanted it that bad, I guess I could make it happen. The 04 S4 is going to be HOT.

 

I love the tech that's been put into the Sti, that's why I can overlook the lack of styling and luxury that I normally prefer. It's an awesome car. But now I'm thinking that the G coupe is just to nice of a looking car not to buy. They're both going to be hot cars this summer.

 

Hell ya! MTM is already designing a supercharger for it, Ya I'd take 450 reliable hp-all wheel drive-luxury S4 anyday. ****, now I've got myself guessing again! damb it!

 

.............and by the time you buy the stock B6 S4 (around $50k out the door) add on MTM's supercharger (knowing MTM I'd say around $3k to $5K) plus fitment costs etc. you're looking at $60k.....hell, why not go for a C4 and be done with it......or wait for the Ausi RS4 (proably around $60k anyway).


The STi will be a steal for around $35k............who gives a F**K what your neigbour or work colleague thinks about your less-than-prestigious Subaru.

I think I can overlook the ricer image and "inferior" build quality for a car which is destined to smoke M3s, AMG Mercs and a few Porches too.............

 

That's what I keep saying to justify over the gcoupe, only time will tell I guess.

 

I hear you, ducaticorse. My dilemma was a little different--I have an 02 WRX and was considering getting an STi--but ultimately decided against it. The WRX is no beauty queen (unlike the G35, which, apart from her heavy ***, truly is), but the STi screams boy racer (and a boy racer who likes pink, at that) even more than my WRX, which was a little questionable to begin with. Still, my guess is that both cars will leave you longing for the other: the STi is in a completely different ballpark in terms of fun, and the G35 is in a completely different ballpark in terms of looks. Funny how that always seems to be the dilemma, doesn't it? :-)

 

Amen!

 

I'm kinda in the same boat. If I don't get my Sti by fall, I'm seriously considering the G35/350Z instead. This is a question that only you can answer. Personally, the Nissans will rock the Subaru for fit and finish. To me, a well built car just seems to "work" better and make me happier. Plus the luxury and DVD-navigation is awesome too. The performance should be about on par with the Sti too, even though they probably won't feel like it. For some reason, stripped down rattle-traps always seem faster than those without any squeaks. If you're all about walking softly and carrying a big stick, then the Nissans are for you. The Sti, on the other hand, is a minimalist, fast as hell, and visually lets you know it. What personality are you?

I'd like to get my Sti so I can see how it fairs against the 350Z that had been roaming our track...

 

I had the same dilemma! But, I found my clear-cut answer: I want the STi over the G35 for one reason and one only (at least for myself):

STi has 4wd and G35 does not. I love skiing; except I hate putting on snow chains! 2wheel drive + snow - chain = ditch

If you have the same need as I do as far as driving in the snow, then you should know what to get.

I actually consider the 2004 Volvo S60R (MSRP ~$36k). It is also 4wd and 300hp/300lb-ft torque!!!!