Fail 'tard wrecks my brother's parked car, suggestions?
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (5)
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 6,826
From: No Way
Car Info: Nadda
Short story, brother was in Sacramento at a house party. Brother n' friends were inside the house when they heard the *skirrrrrt *SMACK* Brother's car was in the middle of 2 other cars all parked near their right side of the vehicles.
Cars were lined up passenger side next to the curb, my brother's car was in the middle.
ShowBoatShmo here, somehow hit car 3's front bumper + wheel, undrivable. My brother, so unlucky, in the middle of 2 cars, get the brunt end of the impact, his rear left tire SPUN 2 AROUND and his whole left side got RAPED. Then knocks his car onto the curb, and hits car 1 and shatters car 1's rear window! SHATTERED.
Any who, by the time everyone looks, car is tailin' it down the road, where it becomes dead and undrivable, dude gets out and starts tailil' it on foot. He has the hazards on in his car down the block. Cops come, get info from host, so he's ****ed for a hit and run for 3 cars and DUI.
He turns himself in later at the PD after his friend lets him know they know him.

The car is at the tow yard in Sacramento.... 2010 Corolla 16k miles on it only... think it'll be totaled?
Anyone recommend a good shop in Sacramento? Lookin' for DBTuned and others for suggestions. Thanks.
Cars were lined up passenger side next to the curb, my brother's car was in the middle.
ShowBoatShmo here, somehow hit car 3's front bumper + wheel, undrivable. My brother, so unlucky, in the middle of 2 cars, get the brunt end of the impact, his rear left tire SPUN 2 AROUND and his whole left side got RAPED. Then knocks his car onto the curb, and hits car 1 and shatters car 1's rear window! SHATTERED.
Any who, by the time everyone looks, car is tailin' it down the road, where it becomes dead and undrivable, dude gets out and starts tailil' it on foot. He has the hazards on in his car down the block. Cops come, get info from host, so he's ****ed for a hit and run for 3 cars and DUI.
He turns himself in later at the PD after his friend lets him know they know him.

The car is at the tow yard in Sacramento.... 2010 Corolla 16k miles on it only... think it'll be totaled?
Anyone recommend a good shop in Sacramento? Lookin' for DBTuned and others for suggestions. Thanks.
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (5)
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 6,826
From: No Way
Car Info: Nadda
Brother didn't get anymore photos, his phone died. Anywho, obvious alignment damage, front bumper, unaligned trunk too. Major part of the damage is in the photo, 4-5 panels
VIP Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 15,425
From: Under your bed, in your closet, and in your head
Car Info: Corvette Z51
I can only see the rear wheel and suspension, rear door, quarter panel, and bumper in the photo. Can't tell the degree of damage to the other panels or to the unibody overall. Maybe someone can make an estimate with this little info, but I can't (even with my professional experience). Sorry.
If in doubt, FLAT OUT
iTrader: (33)
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 7,046
From: Nor Cal SJ
Car Info: 2010 Hatch, 2011 Sedan
The only thing he has going for him is that it is a newer car, so it is a tough call, but I'd say they might not total it. Depends on how much damage there is to the unibody, since that is the hardest thing to fix. With paint and repairs, it will probably come close to half the value of the car. If it is on the other guy's insurance, I'd have them replace it.
Registered User
iTrader: (11)
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 6,849
From: Cheesesteakville
Car Info: 05 wrx wagon, 90 celica alltrac, 66 mustang
Looks like an ish ton of damage. Sorry someone decided to be dumb and your brother had to pay for it. At least dude turned him self in. Looks totaled to me but I am no estimate guy.
for the wheel to brake off like that ima assume the impact was rather large and the car has frame damage.. since the car is less then 2 years old and less then 20k ur brother is gonna get a new car..
Thread Starter
Registered User
iTrader: (5)
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 6,826
From: No Way
Car Info: Nadda
Brother thinks that the adjuster is going to try and lowball the price he can get back, is there any way to battle that? You're supposed to get KBB price right?
Your brother needs to get kbb, craigslist & yahoo listings together to show how much replacing the vehicle will cost.
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 2,504
From: Leg Humper
Car Info: '03 WRX wagon, faster than walkin'
KBB is not reliable. If you need an estimate, please use Edwards.com or Blackbook, KBB is a sales tool, not a consumer agency.
My experience :
If he owes money on the car, the insurance cannot pay less than what he owes (I had a 4 month old car stolen once, owed more than Blackbook said it was worth, but the insurnace had to pay the bank full loan value since they covered the car from new).
Use Edwards/local ads either online or paper to value the car, I did this and got full retail sale price of my Infinity ($6000 vs $2700 insurance company offered).
Good Luck.
VIP Member
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 15,425
From: Under your bed, in your closet, and in your head
Car Info: Corvette Z51
Back when I worked as an adjuster for a certain major insurance company, we used to ballpark car values on NADA.
N.A.D.A. Home Page
If the value of the repair came close to the NADA value, then we ran it by the total loss value estimate guys -- they would scour the state for cars of a similar make, model, and mileage to the vehicle in question, and base the value of of that a few other things (i.e. car's title, etc.). We didn't hassle the total guys first because it cost the company time and money, so we'd use NADA first -- and NADA was usually pretty accurate (it was company policy to check that way first anyway). The only thing that could really throw a wrench in things was if the salvage value was high, but I doubt it'll be exorbitant considering it's a Corolla (it was usually high-end cars that could rack up unusually high salvage values).
TL; DR: Use NADA to estimate your bro's car's value.
N.A.D.A. Home Page
If the value of the repair came close to the NADA value, then we ran it by the total loss value estimate guys -- they would scour the state for cars of a similar make, model, and mileage to the vehicle in question, and base the value of of that a few other things (i.e. car's title, etc.). We didn't hassle the total guys first because it cost the company time and money, so we'd use NADA first -- and NADA was usually pretty accurate (it was company policy to check that way first anyway). The only thing that could really throw a wrench in things was if the salvage value was high, but I doubt it'll be exorbitant considering it's a Corolla (it was usually high-end cars that could rack up unusually high salvage values).
TL; DR: Use NADA to estimate your bro's car's value.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post




