i am so lost, i know a lot about subaru and have been in to them for about 3 or 4 years now, but i am looking to get a new car by atleast august if nto sooner and i cant decide between the following...

2001.5 audi s4 (negaro blue)

2005 legacy 2.5gt (satin white)

2004-05 sti (aspine white)


if anybody would kinda help me a lil on which way they think i should go that would be great... it is so hard to choose, but hopefully i can make up my mind with some help


thanks

 

luxury and perfomance the GT or S4

more on the perfomance than the STi

What type of driving will you mostly be doing? Of course test drive them to make sure you even like they way they drive.

my two cents

 

like to be able to drive the car to the fullest, but htis is a big step or me, cuz im 17 going on 18 in august and right now i drive a p.o.s. 1990 legend and need a new car and i wanna have a lot of fun with it but ofcourse im getting more approvel from my parents about with the legacy and s4, even though i have wanted an sti before i could even ****ing think about driving so.... ya i dont know

i jus tneed something that im going to beat other gay *** cars in and beat nice cars, and its gotta have handling for sure, so who knows

 

but i mean the s4 isnt bad, its TT (twin turbo) so not bad...

 

You don't need any of those cars

 

Audi's are not known for being very reliable... but s4's are pretty sweet. I still can't get past the sti wing.

 

you can always do a trunk swap pleanty of people with WRX trunks who would trade.

 

I love Subarus but the Audi S4 is the Shiznit. I would get the Audi depending on the mileage and all that stuff, but I would definately go with the Audi. Style comfort refinement and a kick a$$ twin turbo, and the quattro is not too shabby.

Oh and by the way, I hate you. When I was 17 I had a friggin Buick Skylark. Yeah!!!

 

[QUOTE=Hoppie]I love Subarus but the Audi S4 is the Shiznit. I would get the Audi depending on the mileage and all that stuff, but I would definately go with the Audi. Style comfort refinement and a kick a$$ twin turbo, and the quattro is not too shabby.
QUOTE]

When i was shopping for a new car a few months ago, it was a toss up between an 01 S4 and and 05 WRX. After much research and lots of input from techs and owners of both, i went with the Rex.

S4 is a nice package, i mean TT, AWD leather, lotsa goodies....but do you wanna be in the shop every other week for the numerous and endless electrical as well as tranny problems that the s4 is notorious for? Normal upkeep on the S4 and operating expenses are probable multiplied by 3 when comparing to the WRX/STi. The WRX is also more of a drivers car, it's easier to work on from a tuners stand point.

IMO, the WRX is a better, more cost effective choice. Either way, have fun

 

i test drove a legacy 2.5gt so i fell in love, i have decided tho thanks guys